Posts Tagged ‘Rugby World Cup’

Pom bashing part 2: the try that never was

December 20th, 2007

Jeremy Clarkson has been crapping on about this ‘try’ ever since they bombed out in the final, and now Mark Cuerto is jumping on the bandwagon and crying in the papers again.

Gagger has written a nice piece debunking the myth and I was pleased to see one of my photo’s featuring as the key piece of evidence in the case against the try. Just for the record I’ll rehash the key facts that the unwashed seem to be missing.

  • When you look at the front view of the ‘try’, you’ll see that his right elbow touches the ground a quarter-second before he grounds the ball. Pics are here and here.
  • When you look at the behind shot, his foot is clearly on the line (which is out) and his elbow is clearly above the ground (Pic with this story). As such, he could not have possibly grounded the ball and consequently it’s not a f’ucking try!
  • Toby Flood in all honesty should have received a yellow card for pushing Percy into a massive TV camera at full speed. Percy was quite lucky not to have been seriously injured in the incident.
  • The final score was 15-6, so even with a converted try they’d still have lost

Here’s the youtube video of the piece of play in question. No Try!

Weekly Wrap ; Thursday 27th September

November 22nd, 2007

Pommy Bashing
ARU CEO John O’Neill has come out and fired a pre-emptive strike at the Poms with

“It doesn’t matter whether it’s cricket, rugby union or rugby league, we all hate England”.

Personally I don’t think he’s gone far enough by neglecting to mention Lawn Bowls, Sailing, Netball, Soccer (especially at Upton Park), Darts, Snooker, Surfing, and how they shafted us in the war. To be fair though, they did take Rolf Harris. I can only assume that he’s attempting to galvanise public support for the Wallabies by encouraging a bit of old fashioned pammy bashing, lets hope it doesn’t have the opposite effect and stir the Poms to an upset in the quarters.

Do it for the Kingdom
Tonga are tapping into the worldwide hatred of the Poms and urging supporters from all rugby denominations to get behind the kingdom in their knockout match against the unwashed on Friday night (AEST). Here’s a few inspirational words from their captain Niki Latu.


“It’s the biggest game in our history. We have a great chance of getting into
the quarter-finals. We don’t want to be going home next week. England is a
one-off match and the losers won’t get another chance to put it right.”
“We’ve got the best team we’ve ever had and have done really well. We
haven’t got the greatest facilities or equipment in Tonga, but we’ve shown here
that you don’t always need that. This is going to be our biggest moment, for all
Tongan sporting history.”
“I know that everyone will be cheering for us, Scotland, Wales, every country … even Iraq. It’s just a massive game, we’ve got nothing to lose so we’re going to give it our best shot.”

Who’s got the biggest balls of them all?
Daniel Carter and Johnny Wilkinson are not happy with their balls, feeling that they are heavier on match day than at practice.

Both were very heavy, they shifted quite a way, right to left, which is quite unusual for me, with no wind.” whinged Wilkinson.

Perhaps the team policy of no WAG’s on tour should be relaxed to improve the respective kickers’ swagger.

What’s all that aboot?
Following up on my blog last week where I suggested that Spreadbury was a tool, this interview between John Taylor and South African Referee Craig Joubert confirms my suspicions.

Video referee, Craig Joubert, claimed his hands were tied by referee, Tony
Spreadbury.

“When he consulted me he indicated he was going to disallow the try
but just wanted to check on the double movement. There was definitely a stop and
then a second attempt to get the ball over so I confirmed it.

“But what about the fact that he was never held and therefore he was not tackled (which means he is perfectly entitled to go again)?” queried John Taylor

“Ah, that’s the problem. We spent hours discussing the protocol relating to the
television match official and it was decided that he should be very specific in
answering the referee’s question. I did not have the right to raise the matter
of whether or not the tackle had been completed because he had already made that
decision.”

Had the try been given Canada might well have won the match and
that could well have given them third place in the group and automatic
qualification for the next World Cup under the new rules for this tournament.

All hail the Springboks

October 23rd, 2007

Is it just me or has the world of rugby gone completely mad since the Boks ground out a 15-6 win over the Red Roses in possibly the least entertaining RWC Final to date?

I will of course give the Springboks their dues and congratulate them on beating not only England, but also Argentina and rugby powerhouse Fiji in their dream run to the trophy and in doing so becomming the second most successful nation at the Rugby World Cup.

This week has been all about handing out accolades to the South Africans, and it’s good to see that in addition to being crowned the ‘World Champions’, they have been named ‘IRB Team of the Year’, Bryan Habana has taken out ‘IRB player of the Year’, Jake White ‘IRB Coach of the Year’ and they have climbed to Number 1 on the official IRB rankings! Surely it’s only a matter of time before they are crowned ‘Greatest team ever to play rugby’, not to mention ‘Immortals’ and ‘Intergalactic Champions’.

Team of the Year
Personally, I believe this title should be awarded to a standout team for the year as a whole, rather than winning their last three games. C
learly the All Blacks were a standout in 2007 as this table shows.

It’s interesting to note that despite playing 2 fewer games the Kiwi’s ran in 1/3 more tries while only letting in 2/3rds as many.
Wallabies defence matched that of the Kiwi’s however gave away more penalties

Number One Ranking
I’ve long been a critic of the IRB’s team ranking system, which is essentailly a points swapping system between teams matched to a curve, but never more so than after reading this caveat:

RWC matches count for double in the IRB World Rankings and a team can gain 1.5 times the standard amount if they win by more than 15 points.

So the Boks overtaking the Blacks massive lead in a matter of weeks was due to several events occuring, all of which were doubled during RWC rankings time.

  • France lost to lowly ranked Argentina at home, causing them to plummet and Argies to shoot up rankings
  • New Zealand lost to lowly ranked France causing a big points drop
  • Argies beat Ireland giving them another favourable boost
  • South Africa beat the now highly ranked Argies by 15+ getting 3 times the usual rankings bonus
  • South Africa beat Poms getting 2 times usual bonus

For the Boks to be called number 1 team despite having in the last 12 months a 100% failure record against the All Blacks in addition to losses against Australia, Ireland and England is just a little crazy. Perhaps they should beat the All Blacks (at least in SA, they’re too good at home) before talking it up too much.

Well done to Habana on player of the year, he would have got some tough competition from Sheridan, Matfield, Hernandez, Delasau and Tuqiri the try scoring machine.

All Blacks Choke.. who would have thought!

October 8th, 2007

This story I wrote 13 months ago has shown to be more truthful that I’d anticipated. Robbie Deans will no doubt be sitting by the phone.. NZ Herald

Weekly Wrap

September 26th, 2007

Pommy Bashing
ARU CEO John O’Neill has come out and fired a pre-emptive strike at the Poms with

“It doesn’t matter whether it’s cricket, rugby union or rugby league, we all hate England”.

Personally I don’t think he’s gone far enough by neglecting to mention Lawn Bowls, Sailing, Netball, Soccer (especially at Upton Park), Darts, Snooker, Surfing, and how they shafted us in the war. To be fair though, they did take Rolf Harris. I can only assume that he’s attempting to galvanise public support for the Wallabies by encouraging a bit of old fashioned pammy bashing, lets hope it doesn’t have the opposite effect and stir the Poms to an upset in the quarters.

Do it for the Kingdom
Tonga are tapping into the worldwide hatred of the Poms and urging supporters from all rugby denominations to get behind the kingdom in their knockout match against the unwashed on Friday night (AEST). Here’s a few inspirational words from their captain Niki Latu.


“It’s the biggest game in our history. We have a great chance of getting into
the quarter-finals. We don’t want to be going home next week. England is a
one-off match and the losers won’t get another chance to put it right.”
“We’ve got the best team we’ve ever had and have done really well. We
haven’t got the greatest facilities or equipment in Tonga, but we’ve shown here
that you don’t always need that. This is going to be our biggest moment, for all
Tongan sporting history.”
“I know that everyone will be cheering for us, Scotland, Wales, every country … even Iraq. It’s just a massive game, we’ve got nothing to lose so we’re going to give it our best shot.”

Who’s got the biggest balls of them all?
Daniel Carter and Johnny Wilkinson are not happy with their balls, feeling that they are heavier on match day than at practice.

Both were very heavy, they shifted quite a way, right to left, which is quite unusual for me, with no wind.” whinged Wilkinson.

Perhaps the team policy of no WAG’s on tour should be relaxed to improve the respective kickers’ swagger.

What’s all that aboot?
Following up on my blog last week where I suggested that Spreadbury was a tool, this interview between John Taylor and South African Referee Craig Joubert confirms my suspicions.

Video referee, Craig Joubert, claimed his hands were tied by referee, Tony
Spreadbury.

“When he consulted me he indicated he was going to disallow the try
but just wanted to check on the double movement. There was definitely a stop and
then a second attempt to get the ball over so I confirmed it.

“But what about the fact that he was never held and therefore he was not tackled (which means he is perfectly entitled to go again)?” queried John Taylor

“Ah, that’s the problem. We spent hours discussing the protocol relating to the
television match official and it was decided that he should be very specific in
answering the referee’s question. I did not have the right to raise the matter
of whether or not the tackle had been completed because he had already made that
decision.”

Had the try been given Canada might well have won the match and
that could well have given them third place in the group and automatic
qualification for the next World Cup under the new rules for this tournament.

Beer and Sport is Digg proof thanks to caching by WP Super Cache!