The fallout from the recent round of CA central contracts continues, perhaps justified, perhaps not. I’m going to throw some fuel on the fire anyway.
I don’t think they’ve done such a bad job. Sure I might just be saying that cause they picked 40% of their players from the mighty Bluetongues… however, looking at the strength of the Bluetongues, this being a team that despite missing the likes of Lee, Bracken, Haddin, Jaques, Clark and Clarke still make the final of the Moomoo Cup, they should be all rights dominate the central contracts.
There are still a few issues I have with the selected squad – most notably having no backup for Brad Haddin. Clearly we’ll need a second gloveman to go on tour, unless they expect King Hussey to do that as well.
Regarding the selection of spinners – lets argue that they went into the selection meeting determined to pick two spinners – one for now and one for the future..
For the incumbent position the options would be Stuart MacGill and Bryce ‘the Viking’ McGain. Hmmm tough choice, perhaps a look at the numbers might help.
| Bryce | Stuart | |
| 1st Class Matches | 17 | 181 |
| 1st Class Balls | 3585 | 40751 |
| 1st Class Wickets | 54 | 762 |
| 1st Class Average | 34.75 | 30.37 |
| 1st Class Best | 6/112 | 8/108 |
| 1st Class Economy | 3.14 | 3.17 |
| 1st Class Strike Rate | 66.3 | 53.1 |
| Test Matches | 0 | 42 |
| Test Balls | 0 | 10781 |
| Test Wickets | 0 | 203 |
| Test Average | 0 | 28.14 |
| Test Best | 0 | 8/108 |
| Test Economy | 0 | 3.17 |
| Test StrikeRate | 0 | 3.1 |
I suppose we should factor into these numbers that Macgilla’s home track does traditionally take spin while the MAFLG prefer to drop in pitches lest they hurt the aerial ping pongers.
So, a proven and rehabilitated test hero, or a 36 year old with ordinary numbers who lands it on the right spot.
As for a second spinner – if we’re looking for someone young then the options really are Beau Repair, Dan Cullen and Cullen Bailey. The two Cullen’s both had central contracts last year and deteriorated beyond recognition, this should prove a real kick up the bum to get them back into form.
If anything, Shane Watson should have been dumped for Dominic Cork.